Formal Disciplinary Meeting Checklist | Employment Innovations

What is a formal disciplinary meeting?

A formal disciplinary meeting is a structured and official interaction between an employer and an employee to address workplace misconduct or performance issues. These meetings are typically initiated when an organisation believes that an employee’s actions or behaviour have violated company policies, codes of conduct, or employment agreements. The primary purpose of a formal disciplinary meeting is to provide the employee with a clear understanding of the concerns, gather their perspective, and work towards a resolution.

Such meetings are often a crucial step in the progressive discipline process, which may ultimately lead to corrective actions such as warnings, suspensions, or even termination of employment, depending on the severity and recurrence of the issue. During a formal disciplinary meeting, both parties usually follow a predetermined agenda. The employer presents evidence, documents, and specific instances of the employee’s alleged misconduct or performance problems.

The employee is given an opportunity to explain their side of the story, offer explanations, and provide any evidence in their defence. The meeting may also involve setting clear expectations, outlining potential consequences for future violations, and developing an action plan to address and rectify the issues discussed. These meetings are conducted in a respectful and professional manner, often with HR or a representative present to ensure fairness and adherence to company policies and employment laws.

A formal disciplinary meeting is a structured and official interaction between an employer and an employee to address workplace misconduct or performance issues. These meetings are typically initiated when an organisation believes that an employee’s actions or behaviour have violated company policies, codes of conduct, or employment agreements. The primary purpose of a formal disciplinary meeting is to provide the employee with a clear understanding of the concerns, gather their perspective, and work towards a resolution.

Such meetings are often a crucial step in the progressive discipline process, which may ultimately lead to corrective actions such as warnings, suspensions, or even termination of employment, depending on the severity and recurrence of the issue. During a formal disciplinary meeting, both parties usually follow a predetermined agenda. The employer presents evidence, documents, and specific instances of the employee’s alleged misconduct or performance problems.

The employee is given an opportunity to explain their side of the story, offer explanations, and provide any evidence in their defence. The meeting may also involve setting clear expectations, outlining potential consequences for future violations, and developing an action plan to address and rectify the issues discussed. These meetings are conducted in a respectful and professional manner, often with HR or a representative present to ensure fairness and adherence to company policies and employment laws.

Four essential questions to ask before a meeting

Is there an issue with employee conduct (lateness, dishonesty, wrongdoing, etc) as opposed to poor performance?

Do you need to do any more investigation to find out the facts (i.e. speak to witnesses or the employee’s manager, etc)?

Have you considered dealing with the matter informally (i.e. having “a quiet word”?)

Do you have a workplace policy dealing with discipline?

Is there an issue with employee conduct (lateness, dishonesty, wrongdoing, etc) as opposed to poor performance?

Have you considered dealing with the matter informally (i.e. having “a quiet word”?)

Do you need to do any more investigation to find out the facts (i.e. speak to witnesses or the employee’s manager, etc)?

Do you have a workplace policy dealing with discipline?

Commonly asked questions on formal disciplinary meeting

What should I consider before scheduling a formal disciplinary meeting with an employee?

Before scheduling a formal disciplinary meeting, it’s essential to gather all relevant information and evidence related to the employee’s misconduct or performance issues. Ensure that you have a clear understanding of the company policies or employment agreements that have been violated.

What should I include in the formal disciplinary meeting agenda?

The agenda for a formal disciplinary meeting should be structured and focused. Begin by stating the purpose of the meeting and providing a brief overview of the allegations or concerns. Allow the employee to respond and share their perspective. Discuss any relevant evidence, documents, or incidents. Outline company expectations moving forward and any consequences if the issues persist. Finally, develop a plan for improvement or corrective action and set clear timelines for follow-up and monitoring.

Can an employee refuse to attend a formal disciplinary meeting?

In most cases, employees are expected to attend formal disciplinary meetings as part of their employment obligations. Refusal to attend could be seen as insubordination. However, if an employee is unable to attend due to legitimate reasons, such as illness or prior commitments, consider rescheduling the meeting. It’s essential to communicate the importance of the meeting and the consequences of non-compliance with company policies.

What is the role of HR in a formal disciplinary meeting?

HR plays a critical role in formal disciplinary meetings by ensuring that the process is fair, consistent, and compliant with company policies and employment laws. HR can provide guidance to both the employer and the employee, assist in gathering and presenting evidence, and help facilitate the conversation in a respectful and neutral manner. Having an HR representative present also demonstrates the organisation’s commitment to a fair and objective process.

Need more help?

All advice is general in nature, for advice specific to your situation, please get in touch with one of our HR Partners.

Our team at Employment Innovations are able to offer tailored workplace advice. If you need any assistance with payroll processing, employment contracts, Modern Awards, enterprise agreements, workplace advice or require access to our full HR document library, contact us to speak with one of our HR experts.